Film

"Shurale" — a Hope That Came Apart

Good cast, beautiful images, and the film still comes apart. On stepping behind the camera too early.

"Shurale" came apart badly, and there was some hope going in — the cast looked right and it's shot beautifully.

Alina Nasibullina is very good-looking, but she should have stayed in front of the camera; she isn't a director yet. A shame, given she came out of the Brusnikin school and has been in good films.

Roma Mikhailov and Gena Blinov both gave it everything. Maxim Matveev is in this company for reasons I can't work out — for the draw, presumably; he's a capable actor and I've never much liked him.

I have a lot of questions about the concept. It does look beautiful, and I'm sure every reference was in place, but I couldn't assemble a picture out of it, even reading it as some kind of mythology. It doesn't hold.

Worth a look even so.

Related texts

Film

European Cultural Studies in Favour of the Glorious Palestinian People, or "It Must Be Heaven"

Elia Suleiman made a film whose hero changes almost nothing — which is exactly what leaves you alone with your own conclusions.

Watching From the Bottom, or "Annette" — a Serious Conversation, Arriving on Time
Film

Watching From the Bottom, or "Annette" — a Serious Conversation, Arriving on Time

Leos Carax's film, in which the end of the story isn't the end of it — everybody sets their own.

Film

Gerda, or a Breath of Air That Freezes Mid-Flight — But Does It Land?

Natalia Kudryashova's film — written in verse, about a city held down by snow, and about whether you're ready to get off the ground.

What did you think of this text?

on Telegram

New texts go out on the Telegram channel — no algorithm, no feed.

← "Michael" — Impressive, and It Plays Lik… A Film With a Killer Turn, Seen at Dom R… →
Message us — the bot replies fast
Message the bot